What we do —

Our goal is to put people first and create optimal value for our residents, associates, and investors.

Our goal is to put people first.

The Western New York neighborhoods that call Buffalo home are truly special, and Sinatra & Co. is vested in doing our part to make them even better. From working to make a difference in local school programs to assisting those who need our support, we encourage any positive community programs that help create better futures for local residents.
Headquartered in the historic Market Arcade building
Sinatra and Co. was founded in 2009 and is headquartered in both Buffalo, NY and Tampa, FL. With approximately 5,000 apartment homes and 400,000 commercial square feet owned and managed in Upstate New York, Illinois, and Florida, Sinatra & Co. is one of the largest private owner-operators of apartments and commercial properties in Western New York.
We strive for a positive impact in our communities
We strive to make a positive impact in our community and to improve the lives of those touched by our work. Our company’s goal is to grow through shared sustainability with our projects, our people, and our communities.
Nick Sinatra, Founder and CEO

In 2009, Nick Sinatra founded the real estate firm, Sinatra and Company Real Estate, a privately held, full-service entity with an initial focus to invest in value-add real estate opportunities in the Western New York region. Since its inception, he has helped build Sinatra & Company’s business model on the principles of investment, management and development to offer a fresh approach that elevates properties to their fullest potential.

Nick’s vision for Sinatra & Co. has also led him to assemble a team of highly dedicated and motivated individuals who are passionate about redevelopment in Buffalo, New York and its potential to become a world-class city. The company is dedicated to a people-beyond-profits model, which seeks to rebuild neighborhoods as sustainable investments that provide maximum returns and social impact to investors.

Under Nick Sinatra’s leadership, the firm has expanded rapidly upon its expertise on multifamily holdings, but soon incorporated commercial properties that include retail and industrial into its growing portfolio. Development projects range from historic to adaptive reuse properties focused in Buffalo and downstate New York, California and Illinois.

Since Sinatra & Co. was established, they have built over 5,000 apartment homes and 250,000 square feet of commercial space and continue to expand on its square footage each year. With a variety of other commercial and multi-family projects in the pipeline, Nick has led Sinatra & Co. to become one of Buffalo’s fastest growing firms.

As a native of Kenmore, New York, Nick Sinatra builds from an intimate knowledge of the local opportunities in the Buffalo, NY and Chicagoland regions. The firm has acquired a diverse array of investors including institutional capital backing from Genesis Capital, Colony Capital,  Auerbach Opportunity Funds and the Arctaris Impact Fund. Today, Nick remains a hands-on manager of the company’s now $550 million in assets.

Prior to establishing Sinatra & Company Real Estate, Nick Sinatra worked in both national and state political affairs. He first worked in Governor George Pataki’s Buffalo, NY based economic development agency, The Empire State Development Agency, where he assisted in the development deal to purchase Geico’s call center of over 2,300 employees to Amherst, NY. Later, he served as the Associate Political Director at the White House where he oversaw President George W. Bush’s political affairs in the Northeastern United States.

A graduate of Yale University, Nick Sinatra also received his MBA in Real Estate Finance from the Wharton School of Business at the University of Pennsylvania.

Anthony Nanula, Chief Investment Officer

Anthony Nanula is Chief Investment Officer at Sinatra & Co. His family office is a co-owner and actively invests in Sinatra & Co. projects. Anthony is a financier and serial entrepreneur who brings diverse experience to Sinatra & Co. In addition to co-founding Chalice Financial Network and Niagara International Capital, he co-founded Essex Homes of W.N.Y, Inc., a well-respected western NY regional homebuilder.

He has served as President of Nanco Enterprises Inc., a New York based commercial and industrial park operator and developer. He also assisted his brother Paul to successfully lead a leveraged buyout of Wilson Farms, a subsidiary of Tops Friendly Markets, consisting of approximately 200 convenience stores, which was sold to 7-Eleven in 2011.

Anthony also holds extensive experience in public service. In 1994, he was elected to the New York State Senate, and re-elected twice in 1996 and 1998. At age 28, he was one of the youngest state senators ever elected in New York’s history. Widely respected for his strengths in fiscal policy, Anthony was elected Comptroller for the City of Buffalo in 1999. In 2002, he was appointed as Deputy Comptroller for the State of New York.

Anthony is a graduate of Syracuse University Whitman School of Management.  He currently serves on the Buffalo State University Foundation Board.

Accounting and Finance
Jack DePasquale Vice President Accounting
Kevin Roe, Vice President of Finance
Linda Nguyen, Senior AP & AR Analyst
Rhonda Packer, Accounts Payable
Joe Farrell, Accounting Manager
Matt Strauss CPA, Assistant Controller
Joseph Bartolucci - Senior Property Accountant
Daniel Gunning - Staff Accountant
Joel McLean - Staff Accountant
Cole Hatley - Vice President of Construction
Matt Connors - Vice President of Development
Will Becker - Project Manager & Contract Administrator
Lynn DiRienzo - Construction Admin
Tim Zawilski - Construction Manager
Darryl Rogalski - Construction Superintendent
Jay McFadden - Project Manager
Alexa Sass - Assistant Project Manager
Investments and Acquisitions
Anthony Nanula - Chief Investment Officer
Jeremy Chopra - Director of Acquisitions & Finance
Robert Carbone - General Counsel
Lou Chamoun - Chief Experience Officer
Tess Vogler - Director of Marketing
Learning & Development
Erin Baker - Vice President, Learning & Development
Commercial Property Management
Christopher Nanula, Assistant Commercial Property Manager
Tom Connolly, Director of Operations
Residential Property Management
Lori Krull - Executive Vice President, Multifamily Operations
Michael LaMonte - Vice President, Residential Operations & Asset Management
Christine Rose - Regional Property Director, Upstate New York & Chicagoland
Donella Singleton - Regional Property Director, Western New York
Saveri Bortko - Systems & Software, CAM
Leasing: Western New York
Amanda LaMonte - Director of Residential Leasing Performance
Kevin Fredenburg - Leasing Professional
Grace Muscarella - Leasing Professional
Tonya Trip - Leasing Professional
Steve Santa Maria - Project Manager
Human Resources and Admin
Kerri Nanula - HR & Payroll Director
Karen Sargent - Office Manager

©2024 Sinatra & Co. All rights reserved.

Sinatra & Co. National Headquarters

617 Main St, Suite 200, Buffalo NY 14203

Sinatra & Co. South

2502 N Rocky Point Dr, Suite 520, Tampa FL 33607